Cleanup Cap vs Broke Line: Hickory Crawdads Hat Comparison
By Hickory Crawdads Official Store | Published: 2026-10-25
Category: Comparisons
Compare the Hickory Crawdads '47 Cleanup and Broke Line caps. Learn the key differences in fit, structure, and style to choose the right adjustable hat for you.
Quick answer
Choose the '47 Cleanup Contemporary Adjustable Hat for a relaxed, unstructured fit with a low crown, or the '47 Broke Line MVP Adjustable Cap for a structured, classic baseball look with a curved visor. Your choice depends on whether you prefer a modern, easy-wear feel or a traditional, sturdy cap.
Structure and fit differences
The Broke Line MVP cap has a structured crown and a curved visor, giving it that classic baseball cap shape that holds its form. The Cleanup Contemporary hat, on the other hand, features an unstructured, relaxed fit with a low crown—it molds to your head for a more casual, broken-in feel from day one.
Both caps use an adjustable closure, but the Broke Line uses a self fabric strap while the Cleanup has a buckle closure. This affects not just the look but also how easily you can fine-tune the fit.
Materials and construction
The Broke Line MVP is made from heavy twill, which contributes to its structured shape and durability. The Cleanup Contemporary is made from unwashed cotton with six solid panels and eyelets, offering a softer, more breathable feel. The Cleanup also features a raised embroidery patch and side flat embroidered details, adding visual texture.
Both are officially licensed Hickory Crawdads products, so you're getting genuine Minor League merchandise.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Structure: Broke Line: structured crown. Cleanup: unstructured, relaxed fit. If you want a hat that keeps its shape, go Broke Line. If you prefer a hat that conforms to your head, choose Cleanup.
- Crown height: Broke Line: standard crown. Cleanup: low crown. Low crown sits closer to your head for a modern, understated look; standard crown offers more traditional proportions.
- Closure type: Broke Line: self fabric strap. Cleanup: buckle closure. Buckle closure allows more precise adjustment; self fabric strap is simpler and matches the cap material.
Product details at a glance
- Hickory Crawdads '47 Bone/Black Broke Line MVP Adjustable Cap: Structured crown, curved visor, adjustable self fabric strap, heavy twill, black under visor. This cap holds its shape and gives a traditional, polished look—ideal for fans who want a classic baseball hat that stays crisp.
Hickory Crawdads '47 Bone/Black Broke Line MVP Adjustable Cap - Hickory Crawdads '47 Sandstone/Red Cleanup Contemporary Adjustable Hat: Unstructured relaxed fit, low crown, buckle closure, six solid panels with eyelets, unwashed cotton, curved bill. The relaxed, unstructured fit feels soft and casual right away, perfect for all-day wear without a stiff feel.
Hickory Crawdads '47 Sandstone/Red Cleanup Contemporary Adjustable Hat
Which cap fits you?
Best for
- Fans who want a classic, structured baseball cap that holds its shape (Broke Line MVP)
- Those who prefer a relaxed, low-profile fit that feels soft and casual (Cleanup Contemporary)
Not for
- Fans seeking a fitted cap without an adjustable strap (both are adjustable)
- Buyers who want a high-crown, modern streetwear silhouette (neither cap has a high crown)
